Skip to content
How to Spot a Freight Broker Problem Before It Costs You.

How to Spot a Freight Broker Problem Before It Costs You Customers.

Learn how to spot critical red flags like hidden fees, poor communication, and ethical issues to protect your logistics operations and ensure seamless, strategic growth.

Your freight broker is supposed to make your life easier—but what if they’re quietly making it harder? Behind smooth onboarding and decent rates, they might be introducing risks you won’t see until it’s too late. This isn’t just about freight—it’s about your customer relationships, your reputation, and your margins. Keep reading to see a story that might hit closer to home than you’d like.

Does This Freight Broker Nightmare Sound Familiar?

Here's Why You Should Pay Attention:

Read this story shared by a transportation manager—it highlights some of the common scenarios that we see on a regular basis. "Precision Freight Partners" is a fictious name, changed for privacy reasons and any similarity to an actual company is purely coincidental.

At first, "Precision Freight Partners" seemed like a dream. They offered solid rates, easy onboarding, and a vetted carrier network that promised flexibility during our volume spikes. We quickly shifted 30-40% of our outbound freight to them.

And the issues didn’t strike overnight—they slowly crept in.

It started innocently enough—a single missed delivery to a Target DC in Minnesota. Six pallets of critical shelves didn’t arrive on Thursday as promised. Friday morning, a frantic call from our Target rep: "This shipment isn’t even in transit. Where is it?"

After 90 excruciating minutes of hold music and call transfers, PFP finally admitted:

The carrier fell off the load. We had a hard time recovering it.

The shipment limped in Monday morning—three days late—along with a $2,000 chargeback. One-time issue?

Maybe.

But then...

  • Another late shipment two weeks later.

  • A missed pickup with zero warning.

  • Multiple delays without tracking updates.

The excuses piled up:

Mechanical issues.” “Scheduling mix-up.” “We’re escalating internally.

But the pattern was painfully clear: they weren’t controlling the freight—they were auctioning it last-minute, chasing margins at our expense.

When chargebacks topped $9,000 in one quarter, our buyer at Target dropped the dreaded words:

“We’re flagging your vendor score for review.”

Now, our account was at risk. Growth stalled. Trust shattered.

What was meant to solve headaches ended up creating them—and nearly cost us a critical partnership.

 

6 key q (3)

Take a moment and ask yourself—are there subtle signs in your operations mirroring this scenario? Recognizing these early symptoms is key. The insights below can help you pinpoint whether your freight broker is truly adding value or quietly draining your resources and risking customer trust.

Insights You Need to Consider

1. Your Broker Might Be Competing Against You in the Spot Market

Many brokers auction your freight to low bidders, which seems efficient at first glance. However, they might simultaneously prioritize their own trucking assets or preferred carrier networks, even when these options aren't the best fit for your needs. This hidden conflict of interest can lead to delayed shipments, higher indirect costs, and compromised customer satisfaction, all masked by seemingly competitive rates.

Insight: “You think you're hiring a partner, but you might be paying a middleman to prioritize their own capacity.”

 

2. Low On-Time Percentage Isn’t the Problem—It’s the Symptom

If your freight isn’t showing up on time, it’s rarely just a planning error—it’s usually a deeper issue with how carriers are being treated. Brokers who pay bottom-of-the-barrel rates or are slow to settle invoices tend to drive away high-performing carriers. That leaves your freight in the hands of less reliable operators who are more likely to miss appointments or cancel altogether. Instead of asking why your shipments are late, ask how your broker is incentivizing performance.

Insight: “If your broker can’t clearly explain their strategy for carrier loyalty, you're probably not getting the A-team.”

 

3. Your Cost Per Load Might Drop, But Your True Costs Are Climbing

A lower cost per load might look great on a spreadsheet, but what’s the real price when things go wrong? Delays that result in chargebacks, missed appointments that stall production, and damaged relationships with customers can add up quickly. These hidden costs often outweigh any savings you thought you were capturing. Your broker should help reduce total landed cost—not just the invoice amount.

Insight: “A 5% savings on transportation can silently cost you 20% in customer trust.”

 

4. The Best Brokers Will Occasionally Say 'No'

If your broker always says yes, they’re not thinking critically about your business. A strategic partner should analyze routing, timing, and cost factors—and occasionally push back when a load doesn’t make sense. Saying "no" is sometimes the most valuable service a broker can provide, protecting you from hidden inefficiencies or unnecessary risk. Brokers who never question your plan may be more interested in collecting commission than delivering value.

Insight: “If they never push back, they’re protecting their revenue—not your business.”

 

6 key q (2)

5. Are You Having to Constantly Follow Up With Them? 

You hired a freight broker to reduce your workload—not increase it. If you find yourself constantly emailing for updates, chasing down tracking info, or escalating issues, something’s wrong. That’s not partnership; it’s unpaid labor. A good broker keeps you informed before you have to ask, turning logistics into a strength instead of a stressor.

Insight: “A true partner treats you as the client—not an unpaid coordinator.”

 

6. "Carrier Fell Off" is Broker Code for Poor Process

When a broker tells you a carrier "fell off" the load, it often means they didn’t lock in capacity before promising the delivery. Sometimes, it’s a result of brokers shopping the load for a better margin, leaving it unbooked until the last minute. This scramble not only risks delays, but also indicates poor process control. Consistent “carrier issues” are often a sign of systemic gaps in planning and accountability.

Insight: “A broker who blames carriers is likely covering their own flawed process.”

 

7. Audit Your Broker, Not Just Carriers

It’s common to track carrier performance, but many overlook holding brokers to the same standard. Your broker is the one making the call on which carriers to use, how to route freight, and how to respond to issues—so why aren’t they being measured too? Audit your broker’s win rate, fallout rate, and communication quality across lanes. If you don’t have visibility into their performance, you’re missing half the picture.

Insight: “If you're not auditing your broker’s win and fallout rates, you’re flying blind.”

 

6 key q (4)

Based on our experience, any combination of these seven issues can cost businesses up to 12% more annually—a hidden drain on profitability and growth.

How Good Freight Partners Avoid These Pitfalls

Reliable brokers:

  • Transparently discuss how and why they select carriers.

  • Show evidence of carrier loyalty and retention strategies.

  • Provide clear tracking and proactive communication.

  • Challenge routing decisions to optimize efficiency.

  • Regularly review their own performance metrics with you.

 



Takeaway: A Good Freight Team Audit Checklist:

Share this checklist with your team to quickly assess your logistics partner's reliability:

✅ Does your broker openly explain their carrier selection and retention methods?

✅ Are you regularly provided performance metrics (on-time percentage, fallout rate, carrier reliability)?

✅ Do they proactively communicate delays or changes?

✅ Does your broker ever push back or challenge routing decisions for your benefit?

✅ Are you spending less time managing freight issues since hiring your broker?

✅ Is your broker transparent about how they handle spot market fluctuations?

✅ Do you audit your broker’s performance independently of carrier audits?